Debating the Neuroscience of Feng Shui

Dr. John Zeisel and Steven Post onstage at the Rubin Museum of Art.
Dr. John Zeisel and Steven Post onstage at the Rubin Museum of Art.

Feng Shui Expert Steven Post + Neurosociologist Dr. John Zeisel at Brainwave 2010.

The winds are mild
The sun is warm
The water is clear
The trees are lush.
– Guo Pu, The Burial Book

It is no secret that our environment affects us.  But how should we design our surroundings?   The February 24 Brainwave event at the Rubin Museum of Art in New York City featured two men who were dedicated to answering this question.  Steven Post, a feng shui expert, represented a tradition (Black Sect) that is open to change.  The neurosociologist Dr. John Zeisel presented work in a field called “neuroarchitecture.”  They engaged in a light and lively discussion, challenging each other and encouraging audience participation.

In Chinese, “feng shui” means “wind-water.”  The ancient tradition seeks to inspire that ineffable power of place.  Although it is called “the original natural science” in China, the truth is that feng shui is based on intuition and spiritual belief.  For example, in his explanation, Mr. Post referred to the “intention of a site” and “invisible beings.” He offered professional anecdotes that illustrated these concepts.  But this is not proof; people who hire feng shui consultants are more likely to experience its effects because they subconsciously want to fulfill their own expectations.  Any valuable experiment would have to be blind.  If people don’t know their surroundings have been arranged in a special way, will they still find more peace-of-mind?  To his credit, Mr. Post many times honored the “rigor and testability” of science and expressed a desire to apply scientific method to feng shui in order to validate or invalidate its ideas.  This willingness to learn and change is a rare intellectual trait.

Dr. Zeisel had a similarly progressive attitude.  Although he has collected clinical data—from his work with Alzheimer’s patients—he never dismissed the unproven claims of feng shui.  Instead of coveting a mystical harmony, Dr. Zeisel simply seeks to design an environment in which the brain can best function and develop.  A particularly interesting discovery has to do with the chiasmatic nuclei, which control our circadian clock.  Damage to these nuclei cause disturbances in temporal routine, such as waking up in the middle of the night or “sundowning” (at the end of the day, patients feel anxious and want to go out).  Studies have shown that if Alzheimer’s patients spend time outside every day, this particular function is normalized.  But although Dr. Zeisel did present empirical evidence, I felt that his inferences exceeded his data.  Dr. Zeisel failed to prove why putting a cafeteria in the front of an office building (rather than the back) would influence behavior.  Or change brain chemistry.  There are intuitive explanations that make sense, but they are ultimately no more reliable than those of feng shui.

Human intelligence affords extraordinary privileges with respect to the environment.  It is important to understand the interactive relationship between brain and world so that we can maximize our own potential.  More studies are needed to discover the neurological effects of place.  But events like Brainwave, bringing together different perspectives and ideas, are tremendously positive for the discourse.  They are the brainstorms of progress.

About the author

Ben Ehrlich

Ben Ehrlich's new book "The Dreams of Santiago Ramón y Cajal" will be published by Oxford University Press in 2016. Ben is a 2015 Salzburg Global Seminar fellow in Neuroscience and Art.

View all posts

14 Comments

  • I’m not sure I agree entirely with your assessment. I do not recall the presentation of any empirical evidence as I understand the term! Instead I would describe Dr. Zeisel’s insights as professional anecdotes that illustrated the concepts he was presenting.

    The difference, so far as evidence goes, is that I am lead to believe there is empirical evidence supporting the claims Dr. Zeisel made about the effects of his design ideas. With Mr. Post there is only the invitation, noble though it is.

    I did not believe that the purpose of this talk was to prove one thing or another. But even if Dr. Zeisel did not prove the reasons for why a cafeteria might go in the front of an office building (and maybe he has outside this talk) – I believe he has proven (outside of this talk) that moving the cafeteria will effect behaviour. This is one step closer to proving that there are Naga – which we must do before we can prove whether or not they are happy Naga.

  • Thank you very much for your comments, Alexander. By “empirical evidence,” I was mainly referring to Dr. Zeisel’s brief mention of a study (conducted by someone else) about the chiasmatic nuclei. Other than that, and perhaps one or two other hard science slides, you’re right to say Dr. Zeisel’s insights were anecdotal. This makes sense given the venue and audience. But I, too, still assume that most of Dr. Zeisel’s claims are evidence-based. I just wasn’t sure that ALL of them are. Perhaps I should read his book, where I’m sure my questions will be answered. I think that we mostly agree, and I should have clarified my distinctions.

    Thanks again for reading.

  • I’ve been noticing the spirit of collaboration between Eastern and Western perspectives everywhere for some years now. For example the Dalai Lama’s work with Richard Davidson on the neuroscience of meditation. With the means of illuminating brain activity perhaps we will break down some of the barriers between brain and world. I doubt we will get very far in a hurry though because although two individuals may experience the same environment, they will each take that information and turn it into their own experience. So as Alexander suggests- baby steps!

  • Hopefully, these tips have provided you with some very
    valuable information, as well as any bodybuilder.
    In recent years, scientific research have found
    that insufficient sleep increases the risk of serious health problems, including low blood count, the bone-thinning disease osteoporosis and neurological damage.
    One the night before I would to start dieting 80 20 rule,
    I would like to say that I noticed any of the kinds of foods
    are beneficial to losing weight and gaining it right back.

  • Hello there I am so happy I found your weblog, I really found
    you by mistake, while I was researching on Aol for something else,
    Regardless I am here now and would just like to say kudos for a
    remarkable post and a all round exciting blog (I also love
    the theme/design), I don’t have time to go through
    it all at the moment but I have saved it and also added your
    RSS feeds, so when I have time I will be back to read a lot more,
    Please do keep up the awesome jo.

    Feel free to visit my website – nutrition for muscle building

  • I don’t know if it’s just me or if everyone else encountering problems
    with your site. It seems like some of the
    written text in your posts are running off the screen. Can somebody else please provide
    feedback and let me know if this is happening to them as well?
    This might be a issue with my browser because I’ve had this happen before.
    Many thanks

    Feel free to visit my webpage :: build muscle

  • I like the valuable information you provide in your articles.
    I will bookmark your blog and check again here frequently.
    I’m quite certain I’ll learn many new stuff right here!
    Good luck for the next!

    Here is my web-site No2 Surge Muscle Builder (Ahmed)

  • This is very attention-grabbing, You’re an excessively skilled blogger.
    I have joined your feed and stay up for searching for more of your excellent post.
    Also, I have shared your site in my social networks

    Here is my web page – 1285 muscle and trig x2;
    Tangela,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *